 |
| while the Taifa tercios form a solid line. |
With Muslim camelry moving up on the flanks to counter Christian cavalry in those sectors of the battlefield, Alfonso strikes on the left. Having brought up light cavalry to harass the enemy camels, Christian cavalry charges in. Facing camels, the horsemen have difficulty charging with their full weight. In the ensuing class, the Christian cavalrymen are repulsed with heavy loses to both combatants. Not wasting an opportunity, a body of knights following up in a second wave plows into the camelry driving them off in great disarray. The knights take the ground but fail to pursue any farther.
 |
| Attack and repulse! |
 |
| A second attack... |
 |
| and the enemy is driven away. |
On the other flank, Muslim medium cavalry charges in to try to break the Christian line. Slipping by the rightmost Christian cavalry, the Muslim horsemen drive back a body of Christian heavy cavalry. Pursuing into the gap left vacant by the retiring horsemen, Muslim horsemen follow up and re-engage enemy cavalry. This time, however, these horsemen are supported by massed crossbowmen. The crossbow fire their bolts into the charging Muslims, disordering their formation. In the clash, the Muslims are repulsed. These troopers turn tail and head back to their own lines as the Christian cavalry moves up to takes its place back in the battle line.
Cavalry charges on the Christian Right are not quite finished yet. Yusuf brings forward another body of camelry to crack the enemy line. The Christian cavalry's luck has run out. The camelry scatters what remains of the exhausted troopers to the winds. Not wanting to face a solid body of crossbow at the ready, the camel riders choose not to pursue.
 |
| Muslim cavalry charge in and pursue... |
 |
| but are countercharged and driven off! |
 |
Exhausted from their efforts, Christian cavalry scatter when attacked again. |
 |
| Battlefield overview after action on the flanks. |
Seeing the red knights isolated in front of the Christian battle line, the Badajoz tercio moves forward to engage. The fight in the center witnesses a titanic struggle with heavy losses on both sides. Exhausted and badly damaged, the knights just manage to hold the ground as the enemy is compelled to retire. Back on the Christian Left, Muslim cavalry comes on again. Again, the Christian cavalry drives the enemy away!
 |
| Badajoz tercio attacks... |
 |
| and is repulsed. |
 |
| Muslim cavalry driven off after a failed attack. |
 |
| Battle lines face off in the center. |
Returning to the cavalry action on the right, Christian cavalry charge into enemy camelry. Despite the reluctance to charge head long against camels, the Christians prefer in the clash and scatter the camels. The Christian cavalry pursues and sees enemy horse archers fall back before them. Blocking the way is an enemy tercio with long spearpoints gleaming in the sun. Rather than risk it all in a frontal attack, the horsemen pull up and end their pursuit. Their hesitation allows the tercio to step forward plugging the gap to the Muslim rear while threatening the cavalry. In a brief exchange, the Chistian cavalry are forced back.
 |
| Camels destroyed... |
 |
| and horse archers evade. |
 |
| After a brief clash, the Christian horsemen fall back. |
Now is the time for the infantry battle to begin.
King Alfonso moves his infantry up on the attack. First to go in is his large, heavy infantry block on the left. They are disordered by crossbow fire on the way in but press on. The heavy spearmen are too much for the crossbow and it collapses. Muslim skirmishers fall back in sympathy. With enemy now immediately on the victorious unit's right, Alfonso, himself, leads more heavy infantry forward in support. With similar determination, the King drives off the enemy. In this sector, the Muslim line has been pushed back! Both armies are approaching their breakpoints at which time they will be compelled to withdraw from battle.
 |
| The King offers up a one... |
 |
| two punch! |
 |
| The Muslim line is pushed back! |
Yusuf does not give up! Back into the fray he sends his Black Guard under the command of Abi Bakr. Abi Bakr leads a charge into the enemy spear block. Suffering tremendous losses, the Christian spearmen turn and run toward the rear. Abi Bakr pursues crashing into Alfonso and his spearmen. Abi Bakr's attack is repulsed! In a series of attacks and counterattacks, the fight continues. The King leads his men forward in pursuit. The Muslim spearmen stand firm and the King's men are repulsed! With heavy losses, the King recoils. Abi Bakr resumes the pursuit.
 |
| Abi Bakr goes in and drives off the enemy! |
 |
| Pursuit carries Bakr into the King but his attack is repulsed. |
 |
| Alfonso counterattacks... |
 |
| and is repulsed. |
 |
| Abi Bakr follows up in counterattack. |
 |
| Last attack of the day. |
With both Breakpoint Clocks nearing zero, Abi Bakr senses that one last push and a Great Army with be destroyed. He is right! While the King must flee to prevent capture or worse, this last attack of the day destroys one of his own units. This loss is enough to push Yusuf's Army across the threshold. The Great Army destroyed was Yusuf's!
 |
| A Great Army is destroyed. |
My! What a game!
King Alfonso manages to push Yusuf's Army over the breaking point first but as the blue Breakpoint Clock shows, only a single pip prevents the Christian Army from a similar fate as well. Had King Alfonso become a casualty in that last melee, both armies would have crossed their breakpoints at the same time. Such a close contest!
 |
| Butcher's Bill |
Great game, fellas! There was a lot of punch and counterpunch throughout and nearly non-stop fighting from the first sounds of battle. Dave B. and Dave G., congratulations on coming out on top. Dave C. and Chris, this was too close to call. With only a '1' point differential on the Breakpoint Clocks, I call this battle a draw. A hard-fought draw too!
Thank you all, and Dave G. glad you could join into this action. Hopefully, you will return for more.
Game duration was about four hours. Oh, the newly installed dice frames worked well too!
Perhaps it would have been better to rename it "the battle of the four Dawuds" or "three Dawuds and a Christian" ☺☺
ReplyDelete"And lo Abu Bakr foresaw that if he entered battle a great army would fall; like Croesus of old, he did not foresee it would his own...."
So wrote the scribe Liberum diem in the year of our Lord 1087.
Neil
Neil, we joked about having "Three Daves and a Chris" more than once. When asked how we wound up with three Daves in one game, Dave C. calmly stated, "It is Dave's Law." Yeah, I swiped the Oracle's good line.
DeleteThat was a fun game to be part of. Well done DB and DG, and well done you Jon. Two games with very similar 'scores' but with different tactics employed.
ReplyDeleteIt was nice to put a face to Dave G, as author of Small But Perfectly Formed. And nice to see Dave C get some decent dice luck for once!
Thank you, Chris! Seeing DC get some decent dice may have been one of the highlights of the game! We should do this again.
DeleteAre you playing Basic Impetus on hex? and if so is there a post on your blog which explains how you are doing so? thanks.
ReplyDeleteYep. I’m playing BI on a hex. Well, my adaptations, anyway. I have not gone into detail on how I do so. I should pull something together.
DeleteFabulous looking game and great BATREP! A fascinating period too! I gave up on Basic Impetus a few years ago- but it can still deliver a great game by the look of things!
ReplyDeleteThanks, John! I find BI always produces an exciting game. Why did you give up on the rules?
DeleteVery hard fought battle there Jonathan and a great report.
ReplyDeleteNone of the generals seemed to like taking the defensive it seemed to be charge and counter charge.
Thank you, Ben! There were some declined pursuit choices as well as some failed pursuits too. Aggressiveness is rewarded but a unit can quickly become over-extended if not careful.
DeleteI'm thoroughly enjoying this scenario, especially as I seem to be in the middle of my own Arab spring. The new dice trays appear to be working well and look very neat.
ReplyDeleteI am thoroughly enjoying this scenario too! The dice frames worked well, indeed! No more seeing dice knocked the raised cleat during play.
DeleteSuper battle report, a very close and exciting game, right to the wire it could have gone either way, very enjoyable read, this scenario certainly seems to give a cracking game.
ReplyDeletePleased to see that you approve of this BatRep. The account turned out longer than expected. Yeah, this game went right down to the wire.
DeleteWell there was no holding back from either side there, it certainly led to a close and exciting game. The narrative and accompanying photos takes one right into the action and your opposing armies looking superb adding to the spectacle.
ReplyDeleteWithout question, neither army held back. Happy to see that you made it through the report and enjoyed the account.
DeleteFantastic battle report again Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Michal!
DeleteThat looked great fun, and I see you use the same hex orientation as I use for Napoleonics etc. Facing the vertices) I think it works really well for linear warfare. This isn't a period I know a great deal about, and the deep formations used by both sides are very interesting. Certainly not classical 'infantry in the centre, cavalry on the flanks'.
ReplyDeleteIt was great fun even though I was only umpiring. Having units face the vertex just makes sense to me since LoF, ZOC, and front, flanks, and rear are easily defined.
DeleteGreat fun battle report and another close run game similar to yours and Richards?
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
Thanks! Yes, similar result to the game with Richard but brought about in a different manner.
DeleteAnother very bloody and very close game that was too close to call. I suppose that's what we enjoy as gamers, if we win of course;)!
ReplyDeleteVery bloody and very close! That reminds me, I forgot to include the Butcher's Bill. Done!
DeleteIt says something about the scenario design that such differently played games can bring about equally close results and a lot of enjoyment. Great report, Jon.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Richard! I agree that it is very interesting that two different approaches to the battle end up with very similar results.
DeleteThanks Jon, for a great game and a great report!
ReplyDeleteIt felt quite a challenging scenario as the Christians, their knights were powerful, but facing blocks of long spear armed infantry with supporting archers, a simple charge didn't look like it would work ( and so it turned out 'IRL', I gather! ). So I tried wheeling my heavy cavalry out towards the flank - not easy given the space available and approaching enemy! All fairly nerve-wracking, but we did get out onto the flanks and managed to do some damage to the enemy there. It was amazingly tense as we got down to a very close points decision at the end!
I must admit that as Alfonso I had managed to reduce my wing of the army to tattered shreds, which would not have lasted much longer... Many thanks to the other players and to you for excellent hosting, as ever.
David, you are welcome on both counts!
DeleteIt is a challenging situation for the Christians as it was historically. You guys did well in getting cavalry out on the flanks and mostly neutralizing the opposition. Before the game, you had doubts that the Christians had any chance at all. Well, you now see that it is possible. DG was a good wingman to have on your side.
It really was a nail biter of a game! It's been a while since a played BI and then it was only a couple of games, so this was a baptism of fire. The conversion to hexes worked really well too. It was nice to put faces to names of bloggers whose output is on my reading list as well. Jon's umpiring and game management was what made the game fun and easy to follow. I shall definitely be in the queue for participants in further games..
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your kind words, David! Great to have you at the table after a very long absence. You are correct, it is good to put faces to names and blogs.
DeleteVery pleased to see that you enjoyed the game and are willing to come back for more!
As a lot of people have already mentioned, a very immersive game report with great figures. Shown with some turns being 'lit up' by standard shots of the table as well as the 'location' shots of a smaller piece of the field. Not in my periods played, but the battle certainly reads like a mighty clash.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Joe! This definitely was a mighty clash.
Delete