Tuesday, March 10, 2020

Yet Another Assyrian Auxiliary Infantry

Tired of Assyrians yet?  Another Assyrian auxiliary infantry stands departs the painting desk.  Actually, these twelve warriors mustered off the painting desk in late January.  Only now are they getting proper recognition.  As the most recent auxiliary troops before, these fellows are from Wargames Foundry. Even though this range of figures has been available from Wargames Foundry for years, it is still a great collection.   
One more Assyrian unit remains before I flip the switch to move on to something else for parading across the table.  Saving the biggest for last, next time, an Assyrian four-horse chariot with assorted supports.  

In other work, the rebasing of the 28mm Napoleonics continues.  French and allied skirmishers have all been rebased from singles to pairs.  In the reorg, several singletons were left unpaired.  These missing pairs will need to be put into the painting queue to bring three or four skirmish stands up to full muster.  Next, tackle the British and Portuguese skirmisher reorg.  A quick count shows a half-dozen or more British skirmishers will be needed to bring the English Army up to full complement of skirmisher stands.

Saturday, March 7, 2020

Judean Spearmen

After a brief detour through the land of game analytics and 28mm SYW Prussians, the unit parade returns to the Assyrian Wars project.

Off the table today are twelve Judean spearmen from Newline Designs.  With simple tunic and shield, these dozen warriors step off the painting desk in quick time.
Even with the long parade of units for this project having already passed in review, two more units remain in queue.  Before I switch gears to other projects, one more unit of Assyrian auxiliary infantry and one more Assyrian four-horse chariot await in the photo booth wings.

After these two units, a mish-mash of units and projects are readying themselves for parade including Spanish-American War Spanish, crossbowmen for the Reconquista, 15mm WWII German armor, two units for Samurai Battles, and a French infantry regiment for the 1799 project.  Add to that a rebasing of skirmishers for the 28mm Napoleonic project and the photo booth will be busy for weeks to come.   

Wednesday, March 4, 2020

Minden Prussian Grenadiers

Taking a temporary pause between the remaining parade of Assyrians and a respite from the heavier mathy-stuff, off the painting desk today are two dozen 1/56th Minden Miniatures (now Fife & Drum) Prussian grenadiers.

These grenadiers have languished in the primered but not painted state for longer than I can remember.  I know they were purchased six years ago.  Primered not long afterwards.  Every time I dig into the bins of primered figures, these figures naggingly remind me to, one day, push them into the painting queue.  With no SYW project to paint towards, motivation was low to proceed.  
Well, this procrastination finally ended.  Hobbled by a broken leg and no means to spray primer onto more figures in the hazardous and wintry weather, I pushed the grenadiers into the production line.

These grenadiers muster from the 15th and 18th regiments to form a combined grenadier battalion.  The figures are superbly cast with not so much as a hint of flash.  If I was to start a SYW project in 28mm, I would be very tempted to use these figures.  In the meantime, get ready for a few more units of Assyrians to hit the photo booth in the coming weeks.
On the gaming front, Kevin hosted a round-robin session of Command & Colors Napoleonics on Saturday.  This marked my first non-solo game since early January.  Kevin set up the Battle of Delhi 1803 using blocks rather than miniatures.  Really interesting battle and solid scenario design.  The three of us each fought two battles for a total of three games.  The three games were fought in about two hours total.  Very fast conclusion to the session.  Scott came away undefeated in his matches winning with both the British and Indians.  Great fun!

Back on the home front, I laid out the grid mat and pulled the Punic Wars figures from storage boxes for a Telamon refight, having clearing the gaming table earlier of Kunersdorf.  Out came the Celts and Romans.  Looks like the battle will cover the entire 6' x 8' mat with armies arrayed from one end to the other.  The Celts, of course, find themselves outnumbered and sandwiched between two Roman armies.  It will be interesting to see how this plays.  

Sunday, March 1, 2020

Peering Into the Charge Sequence of TF-ON

Two Flags - One Nation (TF-ON) is Norm Smith's grid-based ACW rules (see: Battlefields and Warriors).  In a recent replay from Sound Officers Call's Seminary Ridge game (see Seminary Ridge), rules' questions led to a discussion of the charge sequence.  After Norm's clarifications, I sat down to put pencil to paper intent on investigating the math within.  For those not interested in probability theory and a brief look into computational statistics, you have been warned.

First, the steps of the Charge Phase before entering Close Combat include:
  1. Attacker declares charge
  2. Attacker takes Capability Test to assess if charge is FULL or HALF-HEARTED
  3. Defender takes Capability Test to react
  4. If Defender passes test then likely fires on charger
  5. Attacker takes Capability Test if receiving at least one hit
  6. Attacker closes for Close Combat or is stopped short
Given the above sequence, the Charge Phase will require either two or three unit Capability Tests (one for the defender and either one or two for the attacker) before combatants actually cross swords.

What was I hoping to unearth?  I was in search of a tactic for improving my play!  I wanted to know the probability of an attacker successfully charging into Close Combat against a defender.  If successful, was this charge going in as a Full or Half-Hearted charge?  With the two or three Capability Tests required and a comparison between Modified Capability Levels of attacker and defender, the answer is not immediately obvious or easily computed.

The diagram below illustrates the process flow for the Charge sequence.  In the flow example, the Attacker and Defender's Modified Capability Level is 6.  What is a Modified Capability Level (MCL)?  This is the unit's Capability Level modified by any situational modifiers that may be applicable.  A smaller Capability Level is preferred to a larger Capability Level.  MCL is then used in a unit's Capability Test.  Probabilities shown are based on one sample of 10,000 trials.  Different samples with differing number of trials may yield slightly different results.  The probabilities shown in the diagram are reasonable approximations to the theoretical probabilities for each event.  
The first decision point is whether the attacker's charge goes in as Full or Half-Hearted.  In this example, the split is 73% Full/27% Half-Hearted.  

Next, the defender tests to see if it responds.  To affect the attacker's ability to close, it is not sufficient for the defender to simply pass this Capability Test.  To have any chance at repulsing the attacker, the defender must pass the test and inflict at least one hit on the attacker.  Without this hit, the attacker makes no second Capability Test and goes into Close Combat with certainty.

If the defender is successful in both passing its test and inflicting at least one hit on the attacker then the attacker must make a second Capability Test.  If the attacker passes this test, it closes with the defender.  If not, the attacker is repulsed and no Close Combat ensues.

After computing the outcomes for these assorted possibilities, we see that the attacker is expected to enter Close Combat with a Full Charge about 61% of the time, Half-Hearted Charge 23% of the time, and repulsed 16% of the time.  Is this result surprising?

How do these computations change if the MCL for attacker and defender varies?

First, consider the attacker's probability of failing to close with the enemy as shown in the chart below.  As expected, for any attacker's MCL, the probability that the attacker fails to close decreases as the defender's MCL increases.  Two take-aways from this chart are,
  • A smaller attacker MCL is always preferred across all defender MCLs to a larger attacker MCL.     
  • The probability trend of failing to close across the span of defender MCL steepens as attacker MCL increases.
When examining the attacker's charge disposition of either Full or Half-Hearted charge, results are interesting here too.  In the example of Attacker MCL=6 and Defender MCL=6, we saw that the attacker attacks at Full Charge about 61% of the time and Half-Hearted Charge about 23% of the time. 

Notice the effect as attacker MCL increases above six.  Both the probability of charging Full and Half-Hearted increase at an increasing rate of change with Half-Hearted increasing at an even greater rate.  Does this make sense intuitively?  Fortunately, it does.  As the defender's MCL increases, the defender is increasingly less likely to pass its Capability Test.  With that, an attacker is increasingly less likely to take a second Capability Test, guaranteeing closure with the enemy.  Unfortunately as an attacker's MCL increases, the attack is more likely to go in as a Half-Hearted charge.  
While many of these results may be intuitive, breaking down the probabilities embedded within a ruleset can provide insight into design philosophy and intent.  What can be inferred from this exercise of digging into the Charge Sequence?
  • The first attacker Capability Test to determine either Full Charge or Half-Hearted Charge is independent of defender status.  I think this an interesting point for debate.
  • A smaller attacker MCL is always preferred across the range of defender MCLs to a larger attacker MCL.  
  • As Defender MCL increases, the probability of charging home increases.
  • As Attacker MCL increases, the probability of charging in Half-Hearted increases at an increasing rate.
Will this information change my style of play?  It may.  Charging with an attacker MCL above six, may give pause to reconsider.  What will be interesting, for sure, is to put this analysis into practice on the gaming table to validate decision science at work.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

Assyrian Auxiliary Infantry II

The Assyrian Army receives a dozen reinforcements.  Another Assyrian auxiliary infantry unit steps off from the painting table to join a recently growing horde.  As their compatriots before, the figures are from Wargames Foundry.  Rather than the oversize tower shields wielded by the previous unit, these fellows carry an oversize wicker shield.  The dip does a good job of accentuating the detail of the wicker.  
Even with four reinforcing units making it through the queue in February, a number of Assyrian units remain to make it through the figure pipeline.  Three units await their turn for a photo session including a beast of a Newline Design four-horse chariot.

On the painting front, a lot of different projects are seeing work besides the current long line of Assyrians.    Painting sessions of late have been short.  One of the projects finally seeing attention is the WWII project in 15mm.  While a small stack of Zvezda German vehicle models have lingered about for years, I finally put five of the models on the workbench.  The vehicles have been assembled and painted. A little detailing and basing is all that is required to finish them up. 

What else is in work?  Well, after consideration, I decided to rebase and reorganize skirmishers for the 28mm Peninsular War.  More details on what drove me to this decision later.    

Monday, February 24, 2020

Assyrian Auxiliary Infantry

Outpaced by the Assyrian cavalry on display last week, Assyrian infantry begin to make its way to the photo booth.  A number of units are finished and have stacked up waiting for a turn at a photo session. 

First of the half-dozen infantry to make an appearance is a fourteen figure unit of large shield-wielding auxiliary infantry.  While the large, tower shield masks most of each figure, the figures are decked out in a simple tunic.  Figures are from Wargames Foundry.
I spent part of the weekend clearing the table of the Kunersdorf battle.  Having been out on the table for nearly three months, time to clear the deck and consider what game to focus on next.  With the Kunersdorf battle outcome seemingly foregone, no immediate need to refight the battle a third time.  Besides, time to give another period an exercise out on the game table.  What next?  Who knows?

On the painting front, this weekend saw work on a Minden battalion of Prussian combined grenadiers and three battalions of French infantry for the 1799 project.  The French are some of the early French in bicorne released last summer by 19th Century Miniatures.  Unhappy with the quality of these sculpts, 19th Century resculpted the line.  The replacement French infantry arrived this week from 19th Century.  The new figures look great!

Friday, February 21, 2020

Merrill's Marauders

Merrill’s Marauders: Commandos in Burma 1943-1944 - Decision Games. 
Merrill’s Marauders is a solitaire game covering missions behind Japanese lines in the Burmese jungle. The player has to carry out one of four missions, or string all four together in a campaign game.

The game uses the Commando series rules. Each mission card grants the player a specified number of operations points to reach certain objectives. Operations points are expended to recruit the special ops team, then to move and attack on the map. A deck of event cards controls the opposition forces (OPFOR). Combat is resolved using a quasi-tactical system with opposing units taking turns firing at one another. Victory can increase the number of operations points available, but heavy losses can reduce them. The game ends when the player runs out of points.

Game Contents:
• 11 x 17” map
• 40 die-cut counters• 18 mini cards
• Scenario Instructions
• Four page rule booklet

MSRP $12.95

Merrill's Marauders (MM) came to me as a recent ebay purchase bonus.  With no interest in this campaign, this small mini-folio game was set aside.  When I finally returned for a closer examination, I was pleasantly surprised by what I found.

The rules are short having only four pages of series rules and two pages of scenario rules.  The game is a solitaire game with the active player coordinating and carrying out commando raids deep into Japanese held territory.  Opposition forces (OPFOR) are run by a nifty artificial intelligence (AI) engine that actually works.

At the start of a game, the player selects one of four Mission Cards.  On this card are listed the situation, mission, number of Operation Points (OPs) available, number of Recruit Points (RPs) available, and C2 (stacking limits and any leaders present).  Each mission is different but primarily consist of recovery or base building and KIA count differential.

Operation Points govern the length of each mission.  When OPs fall to zero, the game is over.  OPs can be gained or lost throughout the game by performing operations, winning or losing battles, or as a result of an Event card.  With a need to typically complete more than one objective within a mission, OPs are dear.  

To accomplish a mission, a player builds his task forces through the use of expending Recruit Points.  With a limited number of RPs available, the player must construct his task forces carefully.  Part of the fun of MM is that each task force can be composed from a variety of assets.  With limits on both stacking and RPs, a player can be faced with tough decisions on how to construct a force.  With a need to typically field more than one force per mission, tough and interesting choices abound.  Assets that may be included in a task force are infantry, airborne, scouts, heavy weapons, engineers, supply columns, airstrikes, and air supply.  Each asset category has its advantages and disadvantages.
sample playing pieces
Given the Mission card chosen, the player places a number of unknown objective chits on randomly determined areas of the map.  Some of the objectives are real while others represent ambushes.  The game is point-to-point, area movement with most of the tables needed for play printed onto the map in a very organized manner.  
game map
Once recruitment is completed and selected objectives are placed (face-down so that their true value is unknown), play begins.

Each operation (turn) consists of selecting one task force, expending one OP, moving the stack, and drawing an Event card.  A force may only move as fast as its slowest component.  Once moved, one Event card is drawn from the deck of fourteen OPFOR Event cards.  While many of the event cards trigger the appearance of OPFOR units, some cards are beneficial.  If an Event card is drawn bringing forth OPFOR units, a battle is fought.
Moving task forces toward objectives
The number of required OPFOR units are selected randomly with their values unknown.  Combat values for OPFOR units range from a force strength of two up to eight.  Drawing the OPFOR=8 unit is a tough blow since the value of the chit equals the number of dice thrown in combat.  The battle begins by determining tactical advantage.  If the player's force stack contains a leader then he receives a +1 to this die roll.  Highest total attacks first which is a big advantage.  In a very simple series of back and forth exchanges, one side is destroyed.  Luck can play a role in combat.  The player has the option of calling in an air strike to bolster his combat capability if the odds are unfavorable.  Of course, an air strike would have been allocated in the early recruitment phase.  Based upon the number of units killed or panicked, the KIA marker is moved on the KIA Track to reflect the current tally.  In addition to either recovering real objectives or building bases, the value of the KIA Track at the end of the mission is important.

These continuous interactions between player and the games' AI provide suspense and produce many tense moments as the player attempts to complete each mission.  With variability in each facet of the game from selecting a mission, to building a force, to objective location, to Event card play, game replayability is high.  No two games play out the same.  With the Event deck containing only fourteen cards, one could go through the deck in one game.  Given that possibility of knowing which cards may be forthcoming, I only use ten of the fourteen cards with each pass through the Event deck.  That way, I never know with certainty which cards remain. 

The game is challenging but not too challenging although having completed three games, I have yet to win.

In the first game, the mission selected was Operation Longcloth.  I succeeded in the recovery mission and made it back to base intact but the KIA goal was not met.  I needed a higher body count of enemy.

In the second game, I repeated Operation Longcloth.  On the return from a successful recovery mission, my last task force was cut down in an ambush.  KIA totals favored the Japanese OPFOR.

In the third game, I chose the Operation Mars mission.  In that mission, I needed to find the two real objectives out of the four on map and build bases on these objectives.  I found the two real objectives, built bases upon them, and then went off on search and destroy missions to raise the KIA count to a winning margin.  Unfortunately, one of the Event cards drawn was a Japanese raid on one of my forward bases.  With an insufficient garrison, my forward base fell into enemy hands.  Without enough OPs remaining to mount a counterattack, the game was lost.  Still great fun but lost.  

While I ended up losing all three of these games, victory was within my grasp in each.  This is a great little game that offers a solid solitaire experience in a small package.  Components are first rate including the small card decks and playing pieces.  As I mentioned early on, the AI in MM is superb and offers an endless challenge for the gamer with an hour or two on hand.  Perhaps, MM could be used as a solitaire engine for a miniatures game?  MM might be a perfect little game to tuck away for travel.