With a second Battle of Solden Hill on tap for later today, I figured I better get cracking on recounting the first Battle of Solden Hill fought last week. Besides, Richard, my opponent in Game #1 just published his account of the battle (see Battle of Solden Hill). I know, I am falling behind but weather has been good and outdoor activities have taken priority over indoor tasks.
On to battle!
Richard chose to declare for the Yorkists so my Lancastrians are defending the high ground of Solden Hill. Somerset is positioned upon the heights with Lancastrian reinforcements off table when the Yorkists under Edward attack.
 |
Somerset, all alone on Solden Hill. |
Edward and his army waste little time in moving on to the attack! From left to right, Stanley moves along the road to cut off approaching Lancastrian reinforcements while Suffolk and Edward move straight to the heights and Somerset. As Edward and Suffolk move up the hill, Somerset's archers fall back in the face of such an overpowering threat. Somerset's MAA, supported by a body of bill, are uncovered to face this determined onslaught. |
Yorkists move on to the field of battle. |
 |
The Yorkists attack! |
As Edward and Suffolk's archers shoot into Somerset and then retire back through their own lines, Edward leads the attack up the hill. Somerset is ready for the assault. Supported by a body of bill, Somerset's men repel Edward's attack. Not only is the attack repulsed but the King falls dead on the field of battle. Seeing the King fall sends a shock wave through his retinue. All troops under the King's immediate command drop one level in combat effectiveness. Oh, what a blow! Seeing the King go down, Richard paused to consider the ramifications of such an early setback on his plans for taking the hill. I reckon he considered throwing in the towel at this point. No, the Yorkists would carry on without their King. They must avenge his death!  |
Edward attacks up the hill and into Somerset... |
 |
only to be bloodily repulsed. Edward falls dead on the field! |
Picking up the cry for vengeance, Suffolk leads his MAA forward into Somerset. Again, the Yorkists are repulsed! Somerset is proving to be a tough adversary. Unfortunately for Somerset, he cannot encourage his ward to go over to the attack to capitalize on these Yorkists setbacks. |
Suffolk goes in! |
With Lancastrian reinforcements arriving onto the field, Stanley attacks to disrupt enemy plans to bring relief to Somerset positioned alone on the Solden Hill. In a ferocious and prolonged clash, Stanley and Pembroke are locked into mortal combat. Each are grinding the other down to near the breaking point. Finally, Stanley is compelled to fall back. Exhausted, Pembroke cannot follow up. Both bodies will require time to lick their deep wounds. A brief lull falls over the battlefield.  |
Pembroke attacks down the road. |
 |
Finally, Stanley concedes the ground... |
 |
but Pembroke is too exhausted to pursue. |
 |
A brief battle lull. |
Seeing Stanley stymied on the Lancastrian Right, Northumberland decides to turn inward to support Somerset. Advancing up the western slopes of Solden Hill, Northumberland plows into Suffolk's melee line. After a brief clash, Suffolk is driven back through his archers. Northumberland is in hot pursuit. Suffolk's archers stand but are driven back in disarray after having suffered heavy casualties at the hands of Northumberland's MAA. The battle is looking good for the Lancastrians! |
Northumberland turns toward Solden Hill. |
 |
Northumberland hits Suffolk's MAA... |
 |
drives them back... |
 |
catches Suffolk's archers in pursuit... |
 |
sending archers streaming to the rear! |
Was looking good, that is! The Lancastrian position all becomes unhinged rather quickly.
Making best use of the brief battle lull, Stanley rallies his troops and goes back on the attack. Pembroke, unable to successfully rally any of his ward, is at a decided disadvantage when Stanley strikes. Overwhelmed, Pembroke's melee line scatters and Pembroke is wounded. Unfortunately for Pembroke, he is carried from the field by the enemy. Pembroke's ward is broken!
 |
Stanley takes the fight to Pembroke. |
Buoyed by this success, Suffolk throws caution to the wind and attacks back up the hill and into Northumberland. This attack does not go well. Having suffered greatly in earlier efforts, Suffolk's melee line is destroyed in the attack. Northumberland follows up his routing foe and falls upon Suffolk's archers. Suffolk's archers retire with Suffolk's ward broken. Northumberland, flushed with success of seeing Suffolk off, attacks into Edward's ward. This is when catastrophe strikes. Appearing to gain the upper hand in this fight, Northumberland has had enough and falls back from the melee. What? Northumberland!  |
Suffolk attacks and is destroyed! |
 |
Northumberland pursues... |
 |
but cannot dislodge Edward's melee line. He retreats. |
What is the catastrophe?
With Pembroke broken and Northumberland retreating to the north, Stanley is definitely in the right place at the right time. Swinging his ward around, Stanley advances up Solden Hill to strike Northumberland in the rear. First cutting through Northumberland's archers, Stanley hits Northumberland's main melee line. The fighting is over very quickly. Shocked by this sudden enemy attack from a perceived safe quarter and with enemy now to both front and rear, Northumberland and his men lay down their arms. Even though Somerset still clings tentatively to Solden Hill, with two of the three Lancastrian Battles broken, this battle is over.
 |
Northumberland surrounded! |
 |
Edward's Battle. |
 |
Somerset's Battle. |
Victory to Richard and his Yorkist Army! Congratulations, Richard! Very well played. I thought I had you until I didn't!
While I have some thoughts on this game (especially on Somerset's inability to go over to the attack), those thoughts must wait for another time. I have a second playing of this scenario in a couple of hours.
That was really good fun. Thank you!
Thoroughly enjoyable report Jonathan. The game was a lot of fun with something happening all the time. I really thought the battle was lost. The rules made for a super game that felt right for the period. Well done.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Richard! The fun would not have been possible without you at the table.
DeleteFantastic AAR, I thought Northumberland had won the day until the late drama
ReplyDeleteThanks! I thought Northumberland had won the day too...
DeleteI have just read Richard's report as well, and it too conveys the excitement and closeness of the battle. You seem to be on to a winner with the rules Jonathan.
ReplyDeleteLawrence, the game had excitement, drama, decision-making all wrapped up in a near-run game. It was fun!
DeleteA cracking game it certainly gave the impression of a WotR battle in my mind.
ReplyDeletePhil, good to see that the battle account sounded like a Medieval battle may have been contested.
DeleteJonathan, congrats on the outcome , and how well the rules work. And good looking game as well.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Joe! Richard deserves congratulations on outcome, he won!
DeleteGreat game and report Jonathan. Bad luck for Edward, a very personal pyrrhic victory.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Ben! When Edward went down, Richard’s morale dropped too. Richard recovered quickly.
DeleteWhat a great wargame Jon, it had a bit of everything and must have been a lot of fun to play out. A real hard fought battle that swung back and fore and victory snatched at the end! It seems like your rules are working out very well indeed, they seem to give a very good game.
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed the report, Donnie! There was a lot of action, non-stop with the exception of the brief lull. Yes, I snatched defeat from the jaws of a seeming victory. Stanley fought bravely and won the day for the Yorkists. Rules seem to flow nicely with little in the way of complication.
DeleteLooked a very close game. Glad the rules are working too.
ReplyDeleteVery close, Ray.
DeleteWhen you said it was all going well for the Lancastrians I knew it couldn't last! I also thought you meant Edward's brother Richard had won the game at first, before realisation dawned, sounds like a game that had everything and looked great too!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
Thank you, Iain! Yes, the Lancastrian good fortune did not last.
DeleteHi Jon. Nice to see a WotR game with so much excitement …. It seems of course that nothing can ever be certain when Stanley is on the field :-)
ReplyDeleteHi Norm. Yes, much excitement and many decisions to be made throughout the contest. Nothing is certain when Stanley is on the field, but he performed splendidly on this day.
DeleteA close run thing and great looking game Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteChristopher
Thanks, Christopher!
DeleteGreat battle report as always Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Michal!
DeleteStrange, I am sure I left a comment previously - but then, I am getting a bit older! As everyone has already said, a really exciting game that swung both ways until Richard managed to pull a win out of the bag, against the run of play, it seemed to me - great stuff and the rules seem to be working really well!
ReplyDeleteNo earlier comment from you and not even anything in SPAM! Perhaps your comment on Richard’s was the comment you remembered leaving? Anyway, happy you returned to leave a comment this time! Yeah, Richard pulled a Stanley out of his hat on this one although Northumberland’s collapse set him up.
DeleteA well played game! And good looking. 😀
ReplyDeleteThanks, Stew!
DeleteA great game there Jon and one full of swings of fortune. With the King gone, hats off to the Yorkists for continuing the fight and wanting to extract revenge! As I'm reading Haigh's excellent book on the battles, there's a lot more nuance to many of them than would first appear, which is what we all want for sure. Plenty of info on the build up to each too:).
ReplyDeleteI forgot to add I look forward to your thoughts on this game, given my current ponderings on the WotR:).
DeleteThe game was a good one, for sure! Richard is such a fine fellow to face across the table. Yesterday's planned game had to be rescheduled since Zoom had a server outage. no remote gaming possible. This is the first time in five years that I had to cancel a game due to technical issues and it was not even my fault! I may share thoughts after next week's game having one more trial under my belt.
DeleteInspiring game with a lot of great looking figures, Jonathan. WotR is still one of my favorite periods.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Dean! These games are producing more interesting narratives than expected.
Delete