Friday, March 31, 2023

Back to the Revolution!

After a series of poundings on the fields of Ancient Sumeria, I cleared the table of terrain, figures, and haunting memories in order to change the scenery.  With a few encouragements, I opted for an AWI battle in 15mm.  Needing a short turn-around, I chose a scenario fought two years ago as part of the Battle of Long Island.

Today's battle would explore Cornwallis' flank march against the Americans in Brooklyn.  Fresh off his victory in Sumeria, my opponent would be Mark from Mud, Blood, and Steel blog.

The map shows the route of the flanking march as the British approach Brooklyn from the east thereby bypassing the passes through the Brooklyn Heights. The road passes over the stream at Shoemaker’s Bridge. The passage over the bridge is controlled by the high ground around Shoemaker’s Farm and the farm on the knoll to the east along the road.
The Battlefield
For now, all is quiet
until lead elements of Rebel army
arrive to take up positions.
Mark chose to command the British.  I would command the Rebels.  The British Army under Lord Percy has four infantry brigades facing three Rebel infantry brigades.  The British hold both a quantitative and qualitative advantage over colonists but the Rebels are positioned on the defense.  The Rebels want to trade space for time without having their army destroyed in the process.

Let's see how the battle played-out.  

Brigadier General Heard's Brigade had taken up positions on the high ground at Shoemaker's Farm overlooking the bridge crucial to any flanking maneuver by Cornwallis.  For now, all that stood between Cornwallis and the road to Brooklyn were his four regiments of militia, a battalion of Continental Rifles, and a section of 6lbrs.  More American reinforcements were rumored to be on the way to stiffen this defense.

Heard need not wait long.  As Percy and his force appears on the battlefield on the west side of the stream, lead elements of BG Nixon's command are seen marching to Heard's aid.  Heard sends the Rifles up to the stream to harass the enemy's approach while one of his militia takes up a position along the stream below the heights.
The Red Thick Lines
While the Redcoats form magnificent and orderly lines along the stream bank, Nixon begins deploying his brigade for action fanning out to the north of the main road.  Rebel guns open up but fire is ineffective.  As the Redcoats approach the stream, BG Matthews' two regiments of Guards open up against the Rifles deployed along the east bank of the stream.  The Guardsmen's initial volleys tear through the riflemen.  They are drive back with heavy casualties.  The militia guarding the southern end of the bridge suffer a similar fate as the Rebels fall back from the stream.
Rebels are pushed back from the bridge.
Opposite Shoemaker's Hill, BG Smith's British brigade splashes across the stream.  The Redcoats let loose a volley in preparation for their assault.  The fire from the 63rd Foot rips through the militia directly to their front.  Casualties are heavy.  The 22nd's volley does not show the same effect.

Back near the bridge, both Matthews and Pigot lead their brigades across the stream as BG Jones comes up in support along the road.  Pigot, having just crossed the stream, finds himself in a hot place.  The 5th Foot takes heavy casualties from both gun and musket.  The 5th falls back through the 28th Foot. The 28th returns the favor with a volley put into the Continentals astride the road.
Matthews and Pigot cross the stream
 driving back the Rebels.
Back at Shoemaker's Hill, Smith attacks!  The 63rd with the 54th in support climbs up the slope to attack the militia.  Still reeling from the devastating volley received moments before, the militia break and run.  The 63rd gains the heights.  To its left, the second assault with the 22nd in the lead does not fare as well.  As the 22nd reaches the crest, it is sent tumbling back down the slope, shattered.  Lead elements of Parson's Brigade reaches Shoemaker's farm after its long march to the battlefield.  Figuring he would have time to deploy before under threat, Parson's leaves his Continentals in column.
Smith attacks!
63rd gains the heights!
Battle overview
Seeing Smith's attack against the Rebels stalling, Pigot orders his brigade to attack the guns on the heights.  With the 28th Foot leading the way, the Redcoats scale the heights and pour over the breastworks.  The Rebels guns are overwhelmed and destroyed.  If Pigot can secure this foothold before the Rebels counterattack, part of Heard's Brigade will be trapped. 
Pigot attacks the guns!
The guns are destroyed.
Militia reoccupies the breastworks
as Jones brings his brigade across the stream.
Sensing the danger to his rear, Heard falls back to occupy the breastworks.  Not a moment too soon as Smith's Brigade attacks the Continentals at Shoemaker's Farm in force.  Having suffered mightily from musketry while still in column, the Continentals form line only to be driven out of the farm.  Before the British can occupy this real estate, Parsons brings up militia to seize the farm.

In heavy fighting at the farm, the 54th Foot is scattered while the 63rd takes heavy casualties.  To their left, Pigot's 28th pushes the militia out of the breastworks as it retires down the hill.
Firefight at Shoemaker's Farm and breastworks. 
Casualties mount!
Back on the British left, Jones advances upon the enemy.  The Rebel militia look shaky as the British lines bear down upon them.  Volleys are exchanged.  The Redcoats give better than they get.  Within minutes, this entire flank of the Rebel army collapses as men stream to the rear.  For them, the battle is done.  
Jones advances upon the enemy right.
Back at Shoemaker's Farm, having witnessed the destruction of the 54th Foot in attacks against the farmhouse, the 43rd steps forward to take its place.  With the militia already wavering, one last shove is all that is needed to send the Rebels running toward the rear.  Shoemaker's Farm falls to the British! 
43rd comes up from reserve 
to lead the attack.
Shoemaker's Farm falls!
With the collapse of the Rebel right and now the loss of Shoemaker's Farm, the severely mauled Rebel Army begins its withdrawal back toward the safety of the Brooklyn defenses.  Will these Rebel remnants find solace when they return to Brooklyn or will they find themselves trapped and prisoners or war?

It may not matter.  For them, their battle is over.

Well!  A fine and convincing victory for Mark and his British army.  While the Rebels suffered greatly, the Redcoats did not pass through the fire unscorched.  Three regiments were dead on the field and another three were only just clinging to life.

Great fun to see the AWI troops back into battle and double fun to face Mark in another exciting contest.

Super job, Mark!  Well played! 

Expect to see this battle in a multiplayer, remote game next week.  With any luck, that is.

40 comments:

  1. Very nice - as soon as I read ‘shoemaker’ it jolted my memory back to the series of tough contests you previously played …. Surprised about the 2 year thing though, time is moving ever faster!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Norm, I was surprised that two years had passed too!

      Delete
  2. A lovely looking game, Jon, and surprise, surprise, a British victory in an AWI battle...not something one sees very often! Your 15mm figures look great and as JBM is busy creating his own AWI collection using Pendraken figures, I am sure he was very happy to have a game in this era.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! JBM was one of those suggesting a dip into AWI for a game.

      Delete
  3. That AAR really did come across as a hard-fought contest. An engrossing battle and, as Keith said, great to see your 15mm AWI collection in action.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Lawrence! Glad you enjoyed the battle report. I may have made the battle sound harder-fought than it actually was.

      Delete
  4. Back like a sir! :)
    Excellent looking game!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Given that I had superiority in both numbers and troop quality anything less than a win would have been shameful! Jon very kindly neglected to mention in his report that I had at least one turn of dithering about with my two guards battalions - suspecting I had gone too far too fast against mounting opposition. Great game and as Keith said it’s a great incentive to keep pushing forward on my own AWI project. It’d be cool to play this scenario from the American side too I think. I was greatly impressed by Jon’s adaptation of Fields of Honour which was new to me, but really slick, and the 15mm troops looked fantastic. All in all a great nights gaming in brilliant company. Cheers Jon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mark, glad you enjoyed, the game, the rules, and your victory! You are very kind and a fine fellow to face across the remote tabletop. Two terrific games within the week. Hard to top that!

      I reckon you will get an opportunity to command the Rebels if you wish.

      Delete
  6. Some mighty fine mass battle action there Jonathan 👍

    ReplyDelete
  7. Both a great aar & a lovely looking game. Well played gents. Obviously the Britts were flying their special battle flags. ~ Tom T

    ReplyDelete
  8. Fantastic looking game with excellent figures and terrain Jonathan.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Enjoyable AAR, great to see the collection on the table again and victory for the Brits

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Neil! Pleased you found the battle report an enjoyable read. I always wonder how many read, skim, or skip these battle reports.

      Delete
  10. A great scenario and great looking game too. It was very difficult for you though, fighting againt better troops and more of them. Do you think you could have played it any different?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Ray! Do I think I could do better? Of course!

      Delete
  11. Nice change of period. Enjoyable game and report Jonathan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Richard! The change of period did me no favors.

      Delete
  12. A fine, fine game there Jon and well done to Mark on getting a win for the British, a rare thing these days, certainly in your games with Matt that is! Certainly the sort of game where it would be good to swap sides just to get another perspective on the action.

    The 15mm figures look lovely and having seen Mark's first regiment of 10mm figures, I can see him putting on some great games too:).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you approve of the game. In Matt and my Rebels &Patriots games, the attackers typically get blown apart upon closing with the enemy regardless of troop quality. Here, quality can make a big difference. After this game, Mark said he would enjoy giving the Americans a spin.

      Playing a game is a great motivator for painting. We may be seeing more AWI figures from Mark’s workbench.

      Delete
  13. Grand stuff Jon and very nice to see the AWI collection back in action. I seem to remember the scenario 👍

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! I figured you would recognize this battle.

      Delete
  14. Great looking AWI game and figures, Jonathan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very interesting game! I always enjoy reading and reviewing your battle reports, sir. Especially in the battles of the 18th century.

      Delete
    2. Valentine, great to see you enjoy the battle reports especially for the 18th Century games.

      Delete
  15. Very entertaining AAR. Am looking forward to trying this scenario.
    Chris/Nundanket

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you enjoyed the battle report, Chris! I look forward to seeing you tackle this one too. Mark says he wants to try commanding the Rebels. Are you wanting to lead the British?

      Delete
  16. The AWI collection looking good on the table. Fun time. 😀

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! They will be out for an encore on Wednesday.

      Delete
  17. That looks like a tough one for the Reb's to win.

    Exciting battle to follow though mate and it looked smashing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks!
      It is tough for the Rebels to win but they really need not to lose.

      Delete
  18. Great looking game and very generous of you to let Mark win! A hard fought win that the British could ill afford, tactical defeat but strategic victory! Also I thought you played this game about six months to maybe a year at a push!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very funny! I did not let Mark win! He beat me fair and square. Looking back, I could not believe it had been two years either. My, how time flies.

      Delete
  19. Fantastic stuff as always Jonathan…
    All the best. Aly

    ReplyDelete