Saturday, November 21, 2026

The Role of Choice in Writing Battle Reports

Having contemplated the role of choice in battle report writing for a long time, the six Salem Church battles (seven if we count the introductory tutorial to remote gaming for Andy) provide an opportunity to collect and reflect upon these thoughts in repeated trials.  Players made choices.  Dice made choices for the players too.  Each contest produced different results.  Once the fighting stops and the writer sits down to the keyboard, another set of choices begins.  What are the choices a writer faces when reporting on a game?  These choices revolve around how to report the six battles when the core situation or beginning state is familiar.  

All battles began the same but each of the six battles developed its own narrative and character.  The writer ought to identify the different challenges faced because differences make reporting a worthwhile exercise.  Let me briefly summarize what I saw as the key theme of each battle before diving into my thoughts on writing.

They are:

• Sedgwick REJECTed at Salem Church centers on Richard’s decisive decision to disengage after seeing Bartlett’s Brigade wrecked in the early turns.

• Salem Church Game #2 sees Matt put Bartlett on the offensive rather than allowing the Federal Left to be overwhelmed.  Here, the BatRep’s emphasis falls upon sustained aggression and the contrast with Bartlett’s experience in the first game.

• Salem Church: A Battle of Attrition follows Vol’s repeated attacks and the mounting losses that brought both armies close to breaking.

• Rematch with Matt at Salem Church begins with my decision to attack on the Federal Right rather than attempt to reproduce Matt’s earlier success with Bartlett.

• Rematch with Vol at Salem Church frames the contest around Vol’s return to Federal command and his attempt to improve upon a narrow defeat in our first contest.

• Last Stand at Salem Church introduces Peter’s observation that substantial Federal formations north of the road had not always reached the fighting.  I expected that those troops would matter this time.


These are not simply six variations on “the Federals advanced.”  Players choose how to fight the battle in their own way.  Writers choose how to present it.  Writers’ choices certainly influence how the battle unfolds in the reader's eyes.  The writer’s decisions change the reader's understanding of the action but not the result.  Each account can answer a different question.  Choosing that question gives the BatRep direction.

By the sixth outing, regular readers and participants know the key features of the battlefield.  Salem Church, the Perry Farm, Golin Run, the Orange Plank Road, and the dense woods are known reasonably well.  A new reader arriving for the final installment still needs enough information to follow the action.  When a scenario has run multiple times, an initial dispositions photograph may offer just enough overview without marching everyone through the briefing again.  That was one choice.
Salem Church Battlefield
Initial dispositions
A more important choice was deciding what distinguished each contest.  Another account of infantry advancing through dense woods might be accurate but quickly becomes boring.  With readers prone to skimming or skipping, it is necessary to explain why this particular fight deserved reporting (and reading).

The opening game with the Rejects offered an obvious focus on Sedgwick's decision to withdraw his corps from battle.  Bartlett was wrecked, the Federal Left had collapsed, and attacks elsewhere were making little progress.  All that only after playing two turns.  Richard (Sedgwick) judged that disengagement was better than continued fighting.  As umpire, I thought more fight remained in the Federal Army.  Both assessments belonged in the account.
Simply recording Game #1 as a major Confederate victory would have missed one of the game’s more interesting decisions.  Richard’s explanation in the blog post commentary added what I could not.  His assessment of the situation shaped his judgment.  Although continued resistance was possible, that did not necessarily make it probable or even advisable.  In my BatRep, I suggested the Federals could continue.  I did not say the Federals “should” have continued.  An important distinction that risks substituting my assessment for Richard’s.  I was not in Richard’s shoes.   My perspective need not settle the question.  Giving the reader enough information to consider it is useful in itself.
Matt’s first game called for a different emphasis.  His aggressive handling of Bartlett helped turn the Federal Left into a juggernaut against the Rebel Right.  Wofford was handily dismantled, and the Confederate Right eventually collapsed.  Little happened north of the road, so the BatRep followed the fighting that mattered.  Choosing the main action is not the same as listing each successful attack.  Bartlett’s success mattered because Matt kept the pressure on.  Brown moved up to the right in support to distract a Confederate response while Wheaton added weight to the Federal effort.  Those interactions explained the collapse.

Giving every brigade equal attention may look thorough but can leave it up to the reader to assess which events mattered.  I would rather explain how one action created an opportunity or necessity for the next.  Chronicling a battle does not need to follow a strict turn sequence or order of events either.  Grouping related actions can make the fighting easier to follow as long as I do not misrepresent its causes.  If Kershaw moves to relieve pressure on the center, the reader needs to know what created that pressure.  Otherwise, another brigade has simply changed position.
Vol’s first game presented a different problem.  Vol's successful Federal attacks in the center and quick advance along the Orange Plank Road produced a downside.  Taking ground looked encouraging, but paying for it with brigades approaching their breaking points forced some decisions.  At this point in the action, some explanation was necessary to explain the predicament Vol faced.  While the reader needed to know that one more wrecked brigade would compel an army withdrawal, there was no need to explain every step of combat.  Enough information needed to be shared to establish what was at stake.  The same applies to the dice.  A remarkable roll deserves to be mentioned.  The narrative should not discount player decisions that made a single die roll important.  Readers need to know the context.  Was the player accepting a known risk or attempting to escape a worsening situation?
Photographs require choices of their own. In Vol’s rematch, his 2NJ drove through the woods and cut the road, isolating Kershaw and Wofford.  An impressive development, but the New Jersey regiment was isolated in this successful deep penetration as well.  An arrow could show where the 2NJ went.  An explanation was needed to show why its success had created another problem.  Selecting the photograph, writing the caption, and deciding whether to add an arrow are all parts of writing the BatRep.  The arrows also help me reconstruct the action.  Arrows are not entirely for the reader’s benefit!

Knowing the outcome further complicates matters for the writer.  An unsuccessful attack can appear obviously a mistake once its outcome is known.  It was not necessarily obvious when ordered.  A case in point is when Matt and I swapped sides to replay the scenario.  Matt’s earlier Federal victory offered a successful approach I could have copied.  I chose another approach and got beaten again!  My defeat did not prove that copying Matt would have worked better.  We never played that alternative.  In retrospect, my choice appeared viable at the time until Matt’s response muddled my plan.

Against Peter, preserving that uncertainty in the retelling of the battle was important.  I had wrecked two Federal brigades while losing only one.  I figured wrecking one more Federal brigade was within reach to claim victory.  Peter wrecked Mahone and then broke Semmes before I could wreck Brown.  Leaving that assessment in the BatRep preserves something of playing the game.  Removing it would make Peter’s victory seem more inevitable than it felt from my side of the table.

This uncertainty also explains why I wrote my own account even when Peter had already produced his own riveting account.  My goal was not to correct his version, but to preserve a different perspective.  We played the same game without looking at precisely the same problems.  I could explain what occupied my attention. Without seeing Peter's account, I could not be certain about decisions rolling around in his mind.

There is another choice in writing especially when told by one of the players.  Explaining a close defeat may feel like defending it.  How often can I mention that a brigade was one hit from breaking before the reader suspects I am trying to soften the result?

In the first game against Vol, Brown (USA) broke on Turn 5.  With a successful Federal attack, I suspected Wilcox (CSA) might have followed on Turn 6, but Wilcox did not actually break because the whole Federal Army broke on the wrecking of Brown.  That possibility explains why the contest felt so close.  My comment of “One more hit might have won the battle” describes an opportunity.  An opponent’s failed attack does not reinforce the prudence of everything I did leading up to this point.

Over these six BatReps, my task was not to invent six different stories.  The games and players supplied those unique narratives.  My job as battle chronicler was to recognize the differences and choose what would help the reader understand the decisions at the table.  At times, choices meant leaving out some events, emphasizing other choices, and explaining why the next attack mattered.  A BatRep need not contain everything I remember, or every photo taken.  More detail is useful only when it adds to understanding the decisions made and the battle outcome.  Otherwise, cut or summarize.

Writing the BatRep and pushing “publish” does not necessarily finish the job.  Richard’s comments made the opening account more useful by supplying reasoning I could not.  Perhaps that is a sensible place to leave a BatRep?  That is, complete enough to follow, but not so tightly wrapped that nothing remains to discuss in the commentary and post-game analysis.

The players made their choices at the table.  Writing gave me choices in retelling the story.  My account need not be the last word.  Commentary has a role in choice as well.

20 comments:

  1. Wow - you put a lot of thought and analysis into your BatReps Jon - it has left me feeling a bit inadequate about my airy-fairy efforts! We would expect no less of an ex data scientist, of course 😊😉😁

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Keith, I probably put too much thought and analysis into every thing.

      Delete
  2. As I have mentioned before my favourite parts of your AAR are the opening dispositions and the butchers bill at the end. That helps to contextualise everything that occurs in between. The other bits I always enjoy reading about in AARs are those exceptionally good or bad runs of dice rolls which normally mean units are able to pull off something exceptional and usually result in a game highlight.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Lawrence! Maybe I should simplify my BatReps by featuring opening deployments and Butcher’s Bill only? That would speed up my turn-around time immensely.

      Delete
    2. Well, they certainly are the highlights for me. but of course you need all the other narrative in the middle for it to make sense.

      Delete
  3. You put a great deal of thought into your battle reports Jonathan. Your post is a great primer on how to write an effective AAR.

    I should add more arrows to my photos to show who moved where and why. Often a photo without description just becomes eye candy, although with your figures and terrain that would be no problem 😁

    It is very useful when you describe the two sides' plans and how they work out and it is something I need to adopt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Ben! I need to keep these thoughts in mind when writing BatReps always. Having six games featuring the same battle was an excellent opportunity to write up a bit of a compare and contrast. Photos without caption or accompanying narrative are almost meaningless to me and, as you say, become eye candy.

      Delete
  4. A really interesting read Jon, you certainly have put a lot of thought into this post. Like Lawrence I tend to study the starting positions and then look at the butchers bill to give me an idea of how it unfolds then I go back and read the battle report in full.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Much appreciated, Donnie! Yes, this post required a lot of thought. The notion for this post (well, title, at least!) has been in my Drafts folder for long time. The half dozen replays of Salem Church provided the data needed to gather my thoughts and put it all down in print. Very good to see that you eventually work your way back to reading through the whole post. That is encouraging. Thank you!

      Delete
  5. An interesting look back and analysis of the six games and their battle reports. I always enjoy reading your report of our games, and I am often surprised at what bits I either forgot or did not think were key during the game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Peter, and double thanks for being one of the participants! When playing, we often have our own perspective on what the critical points of battle are especially since we often have different goals and objectives.

      Delete
  6. I always struggle a bit when writing up multiple iterations of the same battle, so those are some useful thoughts. A one off is far easier as it is all fresh.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Martin! I enjoy your multi-battle BatReps very much. A one-off report is easier but familiarity in repeating a game has advantages too.

      Delete
  7. A splendid analysis of the games, I am amazed that you retain so much of what has happened and when during the games. Reading the various reports and your breakdown of the various games here, as had me thinking if we really need rule writers to add extra “friction” in the rules when dice throw results and players quite easily add their own?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very good to see that you enjoyed my ruminations, Phil! I agree with you that players, dice, and tabletop situation all add plenty of friction into a game. Why force more?

      Delete
  8. Enjoyed your post, Jonathan. You make a number of pertinent points. Ben makes a good point about arrows on the photos. They help illustrate the narrative and its place on the battlefield. As you imply, you are the editor working on communicating the intentions, sweep and crucial moments. Sometimes just throwing all the photos in the post without providing a sense of movement can be like flicking through a family album without anyone to tell you who's who, where they are and what they were doing.
    Fortunately, you avoid the pitfalls and consistently produce enjoyable and readable reports in which the flow of battle can be followed.
    Interesting post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Richard! Your key decision in Game #1 got this whole ball of ramblings rolling. I agree that viewing a screen full of game photos is exactly like flicking through an old family album or someone’s travel photos having no context or explanation. Like you, I tend to flick through this wall of game photos in the same way. Great analogy!

      Delete
  9. Interesting to have the clarity provided by your analysis. It does seem a good the way to go
    Stephen

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pleased that my ramblings provide some clarity, Stephen. Great to see you back among the commentary!

      Delete