Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Friday Night at the Fights

After my Beneath the Lily Banners playtest with Austin two weeks ago, talk turned to Rome and Romans.  Seriously.  When doesn't conversation end up talking about Romans?  Anyway, I suggested I bring my 28mm Punic Wars collection to the table and give Austin a taste of Basic Impetvs (BI).  Since I had already played through the Commands & Colors Ancients (CCA) scenario of the 212 BCE Battle of Orongis earlier, I suggested porting the CCA scenario over to BI for a test run of the rules.  Gnaeus Scipio commands the Roman Army and Mago Barca commands the Carthaginian Army.
Armies drawn up for battle.
Romans ready for action.
To keep this initial game simple, only one command per army would be present so no pulling activation dice from cup and no initiative rolls.  This would be a straight IGO-UGO game.  Austin would command the Roman Army and get a chance to wield Roman Line Relief in battle.  Let's how the battle unfolded.
Both armies begin with a general advance...
with the rigid lines staying in formation.
Scipio wastes no time plunging into Mago's front line. 
Heavy fighting in the center!
The Roman attacks go in as Scipio comes to grip with the enemy.  The first attack on the left by Roman light infantry goes badly as the warband stands firm.  The light infantry is repulsed but the warband fails to pursue.  Next the Hastati on their right plunge into a second warband.  This combat sees the warband fall back from the Roman heavy infantry.  Next in line is a second body of Hastati crashing into Carthaginian light infantry.  The clash wages back and forth as both bodies of men are being ground down.  After two rounds of combat, Scipio orders line relief.  His Principes move forward as the Hastati retire.  The Principes put an end to any fight from the Carthaginians.  The enemy is scattered.  The Romans do not pursue.  Finally, Roman light infantry goes in against another body of enemy warband.  Like their counterparts on the other end of the line, these fellows are repulsed.  
With their blood up, the warband pursues!
The Romans are driven back again.
On the far left of the Roman battle line,
Roman cavalry drives off and then scatters a body of 
Spanish cavalry.
With the first line disrupted from the initial clashes,
Mago brings forward his heavy infantry in the second line.
With his legion flush with success,
Scipio orders his legion forward...
as Mago sends his elephant forward.
Battle overview.
While the elephant tramples the light infantry on the Roman Right and turns inward, Scipio's legion continues to cause a swath of destruction in the center.  First a warband is destroyed and the adjacent Carthaginian heavy infantry are pushed back.  In pursuit, the Carthaginians are caught from behind and slaughtered.  This is the final straw for Mago.  His army breaks and quits the field.  Victory to Scipio and Austin! 
Mago's Center is gone.
What an exciting game!

Austin did a good job of coming to grasp with the rules quickly and ordered a line swap at just the right time.  With each round of combat, I could sense him weighing when the right time to throw the Principes into the fray.  Fresh off victory, I expect he would give BI another try.  The Butcher's Bill certainly tells the tale of the lopsided destruction on this battlefield. 
Butcher's Bill
Getting the Punic Wars' armies back out onto the table for battle was great fun.  Doubly fun to introduce a new player to the rules and remote gaming.  
Austin said that the game was actually good fun.

Thanks, Austin!  That was fun!  Game lasted about 90 minutes.  We will see this battle out on the table again.

56 comments:

  1. No luck for the Carthaginians? Perhaps you should consider sacrificing some (Jelly) babies before battle?☺☺☺
    https://www.amazon.co.uk/jelly-babies/s?k=jelly+babies
    Neil

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great game with Romans doing that Roman thing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was a great game! And, yes, the Romans did their thing.

      Delete
  3. That looks like a fun scenario to play. Command and Colors scenarios are always entertaining and easy to read. Plus it has elephants, and everyone loves elephants.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The scenario was a fun one. Too bad that I could not lead my Carthaginians on to a glorious victory. Maybe next time? I agree that the CCA scenarios offer great starting points for a miniatures battle. Everyone loved elephants!

      Delete
  4. Oh no! These poor warriors of Carthage! How can they lose so many?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Fun game to follow Jon and it looked great too. Does Carthage get any special abilities like the Roman "Line Relief"?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! No special abilities for the Carthaginians unless you count a possible wider variety of troop types.

      Delete
  6. Great game Jonathan and lovely figures, especially the elephant. I assume you deliberately lost to hook Austin on a new set of rules 😁

    Poor old Roman light infantry....squashed by rampaging elephants. Maybe the elephants should have been in the center to cause a breakthrough* and victory is assured.

    *Taking my advice is often dangerous for your armies and losses may occur. You should seek professional advice before taking it. 😂

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Ben! I never throw a game, ever. Maybe having the elephant in the center may have helped but the scenario but it on the wing so that is where he landed. Your advice duly noted!

      Delete
    2. I know how it is Jonathan. When wins are few and far between I take them when I can get them. 😁

      Delete
  7. Super looking game Jon, lovely collection, nice to see it on the table again. Carthage took a bit of a beating the butchers bill certainly shows the damage the Romans did to them. Good read and it seems like a good fun game too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Donnie! Yes, it was very good to get the collection back out on table. My Carthaginians took a pasting, for sure.

      Delete
  8. Always nice to see Romans on the table. You are a part-timer until you have one, or in my case three armies 😉

    ReplyDelete
  9. The game truly was fun and unlike many ancients rules we've played over the decades, BI makes the infantry battle mean something. Also, units with big impetus values are to be cherished! Now, if we can just tackle the "attached Leaders doing nothing" issue, these rules will be well nigh perfect!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very good to see your initial take-aways from the game. The attached leaders offer important bonuses in Cohesion Tests and melee. They do not do nothing. I wish all of my units could have one!

      Delete
  10. Great looking game that seemed to be full of action Jon. You must be a good teacher - everyone you teach new rules, promptly uses them to beat you! 🤣😉

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Yes, the game was full of action. Really, who DOESN’T beat me when I host?

      Delete
  11. Cracking battle report as always, Jonathan! Looked like a proper fun game on a great-looking table.

    All the best, Andy

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've actually got a copy of Basic Impetus but have yet to play it. Using the CCA scenarios is a great idea, I tend to use Phil Sabins 'Lost Battles for scenarios but they aren't very granular.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Give BI a run out someday. It produces exciting and dynamic games.

      Delete
  13. Super figures and a fun sounding game.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Great AAR. But seeing that elephant gave me flashbacks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Seeing DB rip through the center of a Carthaginian line with his legion from one of our games gives me flashbacks. Remember that game?

      Delete
  15. Great to see the Romans back at the table and victorious too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it is although I would have preferred seeing a Carthaginian victory.

      Delete
  16. Good looking game Jon. Glad you both had fun.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Poor Carthaginians got a bit of a pasteing there!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great looking game and figures as always, Jonathan. I remember when Impetvs just came out - about when WAB was "dying" - a few folks were getting into it. I, myself, haven't ever played it, but heard good things about it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dean! I have been playing BI for years now and think it always provides a very entertaining game. Perhaps I should show up at Enfilade one day and provide a game or two?

      Delete
  19. With the Roman cavalry driving off the Spanish cavalry it was never going to be a good day for your Carthaginians.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Well done to Austin and a decisive victory for Rome:). And a perfect playing length to boot. To my eternal shame, I can never get enthused about Ancients gaming, no matter how much I try!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Austin scored a major victory on this field and there is talk of building an army. Good result! There is no shame in not taking to a particular period. Enjoy what you like.

      Delete
  21. Great seeing your Punic troops on the table, it sounds like fun, whoever won!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
  22. After recently playing so many CCA games of this battle it was hard to imagine the BI rules while reading your report, even though I've played them before. Congratulations to Austin for a first BI win. Your 28MM Punic War troops are beautiful Jon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Playing different rules can get confusing. I guess you will have to try this version to bring BI back to the front of mind.

      Delete
  23. Let's hope that the council of elders will be forgiving of this one-off lapse! Good idea to base a BI battle on a CCA scenario.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Let’s hope! The CCA scenarios provide excellent starting points for scenario development.

      Delete
  24. Great game. I’ve never tried these rules before.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Alexey! I think the rules are worth a try.

      Delete