After regularly hosting and umpiring the many remote games crossing my table, my fortunes changed and I enjoyed a chance at hosting (and playing in) a two-player remote game. As suggested in my prior post on the background of this battle (see Mikata Ga Hara), Mark (Mud Blood and Steel) took up my offer for a game. Hoorah!
With background to the battle already presented, Mark chose to take up command of the smaller, Tokugawa Army. Mark is a wily opponent and relishes the challenge of taking the weaker army in an attempt to upend history. Holding an initial advantage of springing from an ambush, I knew my work would not see an easy path to victory.
Let's see how the game played out.
As the battle opens, Ieyasu Tokugawa enjoys at least two turns of uninterrupted maneuvers to put his ambush into place. That is, as long as no unit under his command jumps the gun and the trap is sprung early.
While Ieyasu's Center stands firm, the left is stirring into action. The Left Wing commander, Honda, moves his troops forward. Tokugawa, himself, leads his Samurai cavalry from its central position in the battleline off to the left in support of Honda. With Honda in place, the battle begins!
While Ieyasu's Center stands firm, the left is stirring into action. The Left Wing commander, Honda, moves his troops forward. Tokugawa, himself, leads his Samurai cavalry from its central position in the battleline off to the left in support of Honda. With Honda in place, the battle begins!
From high ground on Takeda's Right, faint bodies of troops are seen to the front. |
Tokugawa's Army moves into position. |
Proceeded by a volley of arrows, Honda attacks but the defenders stand firm. |
Honda advances as arrows continue to rain down. Yamagata's troops on Takeda's Right are disordered. Takeda's bowmen in the center are, likewise, disordered. |
Takeda's archers are not only disordered but suffer from the barrage of arrows delivered by enemy longbow. Their resolve weakens. |
Having seen his spearmen repulsed in the first attack, Honda redoubles his efforts sending forward his Samurai. |
Fighting uphill, the Samurai drive off the defenders. In the center, Tokugawa's spear crash into the wavering archers. |
The defenders break and the spear push on in pursuit. The Ashigaru spear face Takeda's mounted Samurai. Pursuit is stopped and the Ashigaru recoil. |
Seeing the spearmen repulsed, Tokugawa sends his foot Samurai forward. Same result. Attackers repulsed but the defending cavalry fail to pursue. |
With Yamagata's Right in full retreat, Tokugawa presses his advantage. |
Honda sends his Samurai lunging deep into the enemy rear. |
Leading his cavalry forward, Tokugawa charges into the isolated Ashigaru of Yamagatu. The spearmen hold! Ieyasu is repulsed. |
With all of the action on Takeda's Right and Center, what is happening over on the Left? |
Both armies are being ground down from the ferocious combat but Takeda's Left has remained cautious in its response. With his right turned, Takeda must act now! Having witnessed and almost survived the surprise attack upon his right, Takeda finally coordinates a response on his Left. Takeda's Left, under Obata, snaps into action! First, Obata must withstand a few attacks from the enemy to his front.
Ashigaru spear repulse an enemy attack... |
but a second attack collapses Obata's Teppo. Teppo stream to the rear. |
Launching coordinated attacks against Ieyasu's Right (Sakai), Sakai's Wing folds in a series of attacks, retreats, pursuits. Remnants of Sakai are driven back with great loss. |
Ending positions and state of the Army Breakpoints. |
Mark developed a solid plan and wiped-out Takeda's Right in the early stages of battle. As the battle ground on, I figured my command tent would be under attack very soon. Still, Takeda's Center held and the Left finally launched its spoiling attack to turn the balance. With the destruction of Sakai, the enemy's will to fight was broken. What a tense and action-packed game!
Thank you Mark for an excellent game! Very fun to actually get into a fight and escape with a very narrow victory. Narrow victory, indeed. Based upon the points differential (two points) when Tokugawa broke, I call this a tactical draw since both armies are heavily battered and bruised.
Great fun!
Nope, not a draw at all. I was beaten fair and square by concentrating too much on my left wings actions. Your own left wing went through my defenders like a steam train once they got themselves organised. Despite the disparity in forces you’ve managed (somehow) to create a very playable scenario.
ReplyDeleteWell, concentrating on your left paid big dividends as you ripped the heart out of my Right Wing. Had your attack in the center worked out against my cavalry, it might have been all over for me before I could get my left into action. Seeing all of those successful pursuits was quite fun. Great game and thank you again. I look forward to seeing you and Tony tackle the battle on Friday.
DeleteIt certainly looked set up to be a game full of action and so it proved. Nice to see you actually get a chance to game with you beautiful figures for a change, and come away with a win.
ReplyDeleteYes, full of action, no doubt. Mark is a cunning player and provides a real challenge to get the better of him if only by a smidge.
DeleteJonathan. It sounds as close as close. Congrats for coming up with what certainly looks a balanced scenario even with the difference in forces.
ReplyDeleteIt was close, for sure. Asymmetric armies can be a challenge to get the balance right so that both commanders have a shot at victory. How you make this rebalancing is in the hands of the developer.
DeleteOmedetou Gozaimasu, Takeda san!
ReplyDeleteYou must be pleased to have bested Mark....
Neil
Thanks! Getting the better of Mark does not happen often. This victory will be savored, well, at least until the next battle.
DeleteWhat a great game. Mark executed a brilliant plan that nearly paid off. Soooo close.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Richard! Mark is a tricky fellow and nearly pulled out an historical upset, as did you!
DeleteA spiffing game and I do like those troops.
ReplyDeleteI am glad you approve!
DeleteCongratulations on the win Jon. I see Broom-San tried the manoeuvre later copied by Frederick II: the oblique attack, concentrating his strength on one wing.
ReplyDeleteChris
Thank you! Broom-san is a trend setter, no doubt.
DeleteLike the petals
ReplyDeleteof the cherry tree
Broom-san falls
Just trying a little haiku 😂
Great looking game Jonathan and we all knew you could win.
Nice creativity! Great Haiku. This was a close one and I rarely get a win when playing Mark. I wonder if he will ask for a rematch?
DeleteAmazing and impressive Samurai game, all the more being remotely played, Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Dean! Playing remotely becomes quite natural with repetition.
DeleteA really close battle, the scenario seems to work really well and gave a cracking game. Well done on the win, a narrow one but a win!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Donnie. As they say, “a win is a win!”
DeleteExcellent report eport and lovely pics of two very nice armies, Jon! You did well to weather the early storm and come back for a win, but the stats do indicate it was a darn close run affair!
ReplyDeleteMark is a very sporting opponent to volunteer to take command of the weaker force!
Much appreciated, Keith! The game was damn close, no doubt. Had Mark drawn the next activation rather than me, the result could have been just the opposite with Mark seeing victory. Mark enjoys playing the Underdog.
DeleteLooking amazing Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteThanks!
DeleteGreat looking game and a favourable result in a hard fought encounter
ReplyDeleteThank you and yes it was a hard-fought encounter.
DeleteAnother corker of a game by the sound of it and a win to boot:). A Pyrhhic victory maybe, but a victory nonetheless!
ReplyDeleteIt really came down to the wire. Very exciting contest and a (marginal) win to boot!
DeleteAnother glorious victory! I hope you had fun viewing the heads of the fallen!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain caveadsum1471
Yes! Another glorious victory to hang above the mantle.
DeleteNice looking game (though samurai games often have good eye candy). But SEE! I was rooting for you the whole time and it payed off. 😀
ReplyDeleteThanks! More to come and you will have another opportunity to root for my success.
DeleteNice to see the samurai out again 👍
ReplyDeleteYou will be seeing more Samurai!
Delete