Thursday, March 14, 2024

Battle of Sanguetta, Game #2

Following the battle a week ago, Wednesday, between Brian and Stephen (see Battle of Sanguetta 1497), Mark joined me for a replay of this scenario in a one-on-one remote game on Friday.

Mark chose to take command of the Papal Army under Giovanni Borgia. I would command Vitellozzo Vitelli's Army. With hidden deployment, I set up Vitelli's Army before Mark joined. When Mark logged into Zoom, he faced a green cloud in the background with his army components laid out before him.  Hidden under the green cloud was Vitelli's Army.
Vitelli's Green Wall
After recovering from the surprise of not seeing his opposition and commenting that he expected to see my deployment in order to make on-the-fly adjustments to his dispositions, Mark set out his army.  I think he was joking.  The green veil was then lifted.
Borgia's deployment in the foreground.
When the veil lifts, Borgia's pike blocks are positioned abreast while Vitelli's pike blocks are deployed with a gap between the two formations. Vitelli could be in trouble early if his left cannot get into battle quickly.  For clarity, Borgia's Army carries the blue VBU dice.  Vitelli's Army carries the red VBU dice.

Let's see how the battle played out.

With Vitelli on the gentle hill, Borgia takes the initiative and advances out of the open woods.  On Borgia's Right, his missile troops cover that flank as Vitelli moves down from the hill along the road.  
Borgia's Center advances.
View down the battle lines.
With two pike blocks advancing upon Vitelli's center, the Papal pike block quickens its step and charges into the enemy guns.  The gunners really have no chance.  The Papal pikemen overrun the guns as the gunners break for the rear.  Barely breaking stride, the pike block pursues.  Continuing forward up the hill, Borgia's pike block contacts the Italian pike block in the center of Vitelli's line.  Seemingly unprepared for enemy contact, Vitelli's Italians are driven back viciously with great loss.  The Italians are pushed back, tumbling down the gentle slope of the heights.  Despite having the Italians backfooted, the Papal pike chooses not to pursue. 
Papal pike charges the guns... 
and then drives back Italian pike.
While Vitelli's Center appears to be crumbling, he presses forward on his left.  His Men-at-Arms attack Borgia's massed crossbow.  The crossbowmen are driven back.  The skirmishing harquebusiers fall back along with the crossbow in sympathy.
Vitelli's MAA drive back the enemy.
Seeing the Papal block hesitate, the Italians draw up the nerve to counterattack.  Pressing back up the hill, fighting is fierce.  The Papal pike block is driven back.  The Italians push on.  In continued heavy fighting, losses mount to both combatants but the Italians waver.  With one more push from Papal troops, the Italians have seen enough and break toward the rear.     
Heavy fighting in the center...
as the pike blocks grind each other down.
Witnessing the destruction of the Italian pikemen, Vitelli's second pike block wheels to better bring the enemy to bear.  In the distance, Borgia's MAA work their way around the enemy right.  In the foreground, Vitelli's MAA continue to pressure Borgia's Right.  Vitelli's MMA sweep around and strike the crossbow.  The crossbowmen are scattered as the MAA move into the Papal rear. 
Vitelli's MAA empty the Papal rear
after destroying enemy crossbow.
With the enemy right collapsing, Vitelli's second pike block pushes forward toward the center.  As the pikemen approach the enemy, the Papal pike charges into Vitelli's pikemen.  In very heavy fighting, the two blocks grind each other down until both formations are cut in numbers by two-thirds.  Finally, Vitelli's pikemen are forced back.  Exhausted, Borgia's pike block fails to follow-up.   
Vitelli's pike heads back into the center.
Push of pike grinds down both combatants.
Battle situation as battle breaks down
into a number of smaller clashes.
Seeing the Papal rear devoid of troops, Vitelli swings his MAA about to bring the enemy guns into sight.  Vitelli strikes the Papal guns before they can respond to this new threat.  The guns are easily overrun.  If Vitelli can quickly swing around, he will be able to lead a charge into the rear of the enemy Landsknecht pike block.  Whichever commander destroys the next enemy unit, the spoils of war and victory fall to him.
Vitelli free to roam in the Papal rear.
Vitelli overruns the guns!
Unfortunately, time has run out for Vitelli.  Borgia leads his MAA into an attack against the remnants of an enemy pike block as it retreats.  Wavering, the pikemen can take no more.  The pike block dissolves and the battle is over.  
Borgia breaks the enemy pike block.
Borgia, the Papal Army, and Mark are victorious!  Well done, Mark!

While the battle began with a strong push by Borgia's Papal Army in the center, its hesitation after successfully driving the enemy back gave Vitelli just enough time to regroup and launch a counterstroke.  Vitelli made a valiant attempt to rebalance the fight by emptying the Papal rear of troops.  The race was then on to break the enemy's will to fight.  Unfortunately for Vitelli, it would be his army that was the first to collapse.

Great game!  After a dismal start, Vitelli fought back to see victory almost within his grasp.  Still, it was not to be and Borgia (and Mark) emerged victorious in a hard-fought battle.

Mark is a very tough foe.  In a one-on-one battle, I am unsure if I have ever won against my formidable opponent.

Maybe next time, my friend.

Tuesday, March 12, 2024

In the Eye of the Storm

With three game sessions last week and another three slated for this week, Monday found me, figuratively, in the eye of the storm.  Having five games spanning Friday and Saturday, and Nancy's birthday party on Sunday, Monday saw a little respite before games kick off again on Tuesday.  Yes, I could have spent time working to hammer out the battle report from Friday's excellent game with Mark.  Instead, I spent much of the day with domestic tasks interspersed with a few painting sessions.  I will get to Friday's battle report before too long but not before I fall farther behind as upcoming games keep the backlog of battle chronicles growing.  
Anyway, off the painting desk today is the Hanoverian Lieb-Regiment Reuter.  These twelve figures are Eureka Miniatures. Still plenty of SYW/WAS cavalry in the queue.  Even a handful of Biblical units are readying themselves for action. 

Having seen the Great Italian Wars collection out for two battles, thus far, and more coming up, an order to Foundry went out.  The packets of figures arrived this week and have been put into ziplocks for temporary storage.  What did I order?  Well, Gendarmes and Men-at-Arms for the mounted arm, and three dozen Swiss foot.  Setting up the Sanguetta scenario, I discovered I lacked skirmish stands of crossbow.  In addition to the crossbowmen, I added some harquebusiers too.  Simply for good measure.  
Stew (from A Terrible Loss of Lead and Wealth) might claim that today's post is a Peanut Butter and JellyTM post to buy time for more important topics, like battle reports.  

Stew would be right.

Saturday, March 9, 2024

Battle of Sanguetta 1497

Perhaps having beaten a dead horse with six battles of Lake Trasimene, time to switch gears and periods.

Lots of periods from which to choose but bringing the Great Italian Wars collection to the table won an unscientific poll.  With two new players to Basic Impetvs (and one player new to remote gaming), a small, introductory scenario seemed appropriate.  Armed with the new scenario book, War Gaming Scenarios by Rodolfo Maria Verginella in hand, I settle on the small, 1497 Battle of Sanguetta.

Players were given a battle briefing and asked to prepare their battle deployments, unknown to their opponent.
Battlefield deployment zones
Opposing Armies
Both players (Stephen as Vitelli and Brian as Borgia) sent their deployments to me ahead of game day and I set the table.  When players arrived for battle, the table looked as,
Armies deployed for battle.
From the Papal deployments, Brian looks to be channeling Frederick and his Oblique Maneuver rather than Machiavelli!  Perhaps Frederick was a student of Machiavelli?
Borgia's Army
Vitelli's Army
Battle deployment overview.
With armies deployed and a quick overview of the rules given, on to battle.

As Borgia's artillery, crossbow, and harquebusiers pin the enemy in place, the pike blocks and the Men-at-Arms march through the open woods in an effort to turn the enemy's flank.  At the first sound of the guns, Borgia's guns find their mark and destroy Vitelli's artillery.  The battle is off to a good start for Borgia! 
Vitelli's artillery destroyed!
Quite annoyed with this result, Vitelli orders his Men-at-Arms (MAA) forward.  As the MAA reach the crest of the gently rolling hill, Vitelli charges down and into the awaiting guns.  The outcome is decided quickly.  Borgia's guns are overrun. 
Vitelli attacks the enemy guns...
and Borgia’s guns are quickly destroyed.
With success against the guns and his MAA now exposed, Vitelli orders his missile troops to advance down from the hill to engage the enemy.  Vitelli's pike blocks turn to counter Borgia's outflanking maneuver.  Seeing enemy MAA almost upon his flank, Borgia turns his pike blocks to meet this sudden threat.
Vitelli sets his army into motion.
With enemy near, Borgia turns to face this threat. 
Having seen his battle line pierced by Vitelli's MAA, Borgia's crossbowmen turn to give the enemy horsemen a volley as they pass through the lines.  Excited by the opportunity to shoot into the MAA's rear, Borgia's crossbowmen forget their own safety.  These impetuous fellows are, in turn, attacked in rear by Vitelli's crossbow and dispatched.   
Passing shot at Vitelli's MAA.
A fleeting opportunity turns into catastrophe.
Despite enemy cavalry to their rear, Borgia's pikemen press forward to engage Vitelli's pikemen.  Not wanting to give up the initiative, Vitelli's smaller pike block (of two) charges down from the high ground.  The Landsknechts stand in their way.  Fighting through the Landsknecht's dopplesoldners, Vitelli's pikemen push the Landsknechts back.  Vitelli's pikemen continue to press on.
First clash of pike!
Landsknechts are pushed back.
Meanwhile, having seen their pikemen press on toward Vitelli's pikemen on the hill, a clear path opens and Borgia sees Vitelli leading his MAA through the woods.  Not wasting a minute, Borgia sends his MAA to attack.  Not expecting enemy heavy cavalry upon his flank, Vitelli's heavy cavalry break.  Vitelli, himself, falls on the field during the chaos.  
Vitelli falls in battle!
While enemy horsemen are being dispersed, the fight at the hill continues.  With Borgia leading the way, the Landsknechts push back, driving the enemy back up the hill.  Vitelli's lead pike block falls back upon support.
Borgia and his Landsknechts push the enemy back.
Overview of the situation.
Although suffering heavily from losses, Borgia encourages the Landsknechts to take the fight to the enemy.  Striking the rightmost enemy pike block, the two formations grind each other down.  With Vitelli's pike block fresh and larger, Borgia's Landsknechts are fighting an uphill battle (literally!).  The Landsknechts' numbers are dwindling as pikemen stream to the rear.  Finally, the Landsknechts can take no more and break. Borgia does not survive the battle.  
Borgia orders one more charge!
Fighting is hard as the Landsknechts waver.
Landsknechts break and Borgia is killed.
With the breaking of the Landsknechts and the death of Borgia, the battle is over.  Victory to Vitelli and the Orsinis!

While Stephen came away with battle honors, Brian put up a very hard fight.  In the end, the result was close.  Very close.  The battle was not decided until the final loss of the Landsknechts.  Both armies were teetering on the break point.

Both players fought a good fight using a ruleset unfamiliar to both.  Well, Brian, at least, had read through the rules beforehand but had never played a game.  Both adapted quickly and play was smooth.  Game lasted about two hours.  Thanks to both players for a fun encounter and a chance to get my Italian Wars collection back out and onto the gaming table.

What did Brian and Stephen think of the rules and the game?  Well, they are both willing to return to the table for a rematch next week after swapping sides.  That says something, I reckon.

Expect more battles at Sanguetta over the coming week.

Tuesday, March 5, 2024

Location, Gaming, and the Magic Quadrant

The last time we looked at the Wargames, Soldiers, and Strategy's Great Wargaming Survey, the topic examined the possibility that survey respondents' location is an influencer in driving gaming preferences.  That analysis focused on a series of pairwise comparisons of location against table size, game venue, group size, gaming frequency, game length and favorite wargaming period.  Almost more than a handful of attributes.  Each attribute had multiple levels (treatments) too.  Only those survey respondents who classified themselves as primarily historical wargamers were included.  As a refresher, these pairwise comparison analyses are found at Does Location Influence How We Game?. The survey results demonstrated that location not only plays a role in how we game but also what we play.  

The blog post summary suggested that a further "next step" in the analysis would be to combine these pairwise comparisons into a multi-dimensional, holistic examination of group association.  Today's analysis is an extension of the pairwise comparisons seen earlier and addresses the multi-dimensional question.

Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA)
Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA), briefly, is a statistical technique from which any underlying structure in the categorical response survey data may be detected. MCA is an extension of Simple Correspondence Analysis.  The results are then presented in graphical form in two-dimensional, Euclidean space.  Interpretations are understandable and intuitive without knowing the underlying technique.  Interpretation, though, can be as much art as science.  Interpretations are only tendencies and associations based upon the survey data.

Data Reduction
Plotting the analysis outcomes over seven attributes each having multiple levels makes for a messy plot.  In order to make the resulting plot more manageable and (hopefully) more intelligible, data reduction techniques are introduced.  The main technique utilized is simply re-binning levels of each attribute to reduce the number of levels under consideration.

After re-binning, the levels for each of the attributes are:
  • Location: UK (and Ireland), USA (and Canada), Europe (Continental Europe and Scandinavia), Australasia (Australia and New Zealand).
  • Wargaming Periods:  Only the top periods remain.  They are: WWII, Napoleonics, Ancients, Medievals, 18th Century, ACW.
  • Game Frequency: Weekly, Monthly, Less Than Monthly.
  • Game Length: 1-2 hours, 2-3 hours, 3+ hours.
  • Game Type: Scenario, Campaign, Pick-up.
  • Game Venue: Solo, At home, At club, At game store, Friend's home.
  • Table Size: Small, Average, Large.  
Now consider the interactions between the seven wargaming attributes.  When analyzed using MCA, the seven categorical attributes with their accompanying levels are plotted in two-dimensional space as illustrated in the graphic below.
Some of the levels are clustering near others while some levels are seemingly plotted as outliers.  Like correspondence analysis, attributes plotted along the origins exhibit little differentiation.  Those levels farther from the origin demonstrate more separation and distinction.  At this stage, inferences can be difficult to make.  Adding in the origin reference lines help to accentuate these differences.  Reference lines also allow distinctions between each of the four quadrants.
Magic Quadrant
Once the plot is divided into quadrants, each quadrant is examined to discover any associations between the levels of the various attributes.  For ease of visual identification, each quadrant is color-coded.
Does each quadrant present a specific collection of levels and attributes?  Are levels of an attribute unique to a particular quadrant?  Is there overlap?  Can any useful inferences be gleaned from the MCA?

Since gamer location was the motivation for these studies, let's examine Location.  The Magic Quadrant shows that each location level appears in one quadrant only.  There is no overlap of two in the same quadrant.  That result suggests that location does influence how gamers game.  Do other general tendencies surface from the analysis?  Are there tendencies peculiar to a specific region?  Summarizing by quadrant produces the following tendencies and associations:
  • UK (Orange Quad): Tend to meet weekly at a club for two to three hours per session.  Clubs tend to have ten or more gamers.  Perhaps a slight tendency to game 18th Century and WWII more than other regions.
  • Australasia (Yellow Quad): Tend to game monthly at either a friend's house or at a game store.  Games tend to be played on large tables with between five and nine players.  Game sessions last three or more hours.  May feature Napoleonics more than other regions.
  • USA (Green Quad):  Tend to game less often than either UK or Australasia, at home, and with one to four players.  Tend to game ACW more often than other regions.
  • Europe (Blue Quad):  Tend to game solo, on small tables, with games only one to two hours in duration.  They tend to play Ancients and Medievals more than other regions.     

  • Interesting results.  MCA can provide a data-driven dimension to uncovering tendencies of gamers across the globe.  Does location influence what is played and under which conditions?  The survey results suggest, that yes, it does.

    Of course, these are broad generalizations of the tendencies provided by respondents to the survey.  We are individuals.  Still, does this present a picture of the wargaming hobby that is familiar to you?

Saturday, March 2, 2024

Flag-Flying Parade

Having cleared the table from the long-running Lake Trasimene series of battles, thoughts turned to the next collection to see action on the table.  After some discussion and encouragement, the 28mm Great Italian Wars collection was picked as the next focus of gaming.  Of course, my decision may have been influenced just a little bit by the recent arrival of Rodolfo Verginella's, War Game Scenarios: The Italian Wars Battles 1494-1559.

Since the Punic Wars figures have been packed away and the table cleared, I thought, why not pull all of the figures from boxes and bring the whole collection out for a parade.  Why not, indeed?  A parade will give me a chance to see exactly what I have and what I may be tempted to add to the collection.

After arraying the armies out on the table, the project headcount shows,
  • 6 guns
  • 77 horse
  • 525 foot
Figures are a mix of Wargames Foundry, Old Glory, The Assault Group, Artizan, Perry Miniatures, and Casting Room Miniatures.  Nice assortment, I think.

Without further ado, on to the parade...







Anything of note lacking in the collection?  The collection could use more mounted Men-at-Arms and several units of crossbow skirmishers. That is only a first cut.  There may be more to add.  Eight pike blocks ought to be sufficient, no?  I may place a small Foundry/Casting Room Miniatures order but it will be relatively small.  I want to maintain the, now, two-month progress on keeping The Lead Pile count in deficit goal for 2024.  This goal took a modest blow with the receipt of Newline Designs' shortened February sale.  I need to focus more on painting.
Results of Newlines' February sale. 
First game is slated for next week in a very small battle suitable for two players.  The players are both new to Basic Impetvs and one is new to remote gaming.

Should be fun.