In the last Battle of Mortimer's Cross (see The Man Who Won't Be King), the game saw Edward IV wounded and carried away by the enemy. That day was a hard one for Edward.
Following that episode, Chris, and the Two Dave's joined in to refight this battle for a fourth time last week. With only three players, Dave B. (DB) took command of the entire Yorkist Army (red dice) alone while Chris and Dave C. (DC) split the Lancastrian command (blue dice). DC would take command of the army and Pembroke's center Battle with Chris taking command of the two Lancastrian wings.
As a refresher, initial deployments looked thusly,
 |
Initial deployments |
As the title suggests, Edward may have seen another hard day on the field. Let's find out!
When the battle begins, Edward places Herbert and his own command on Engage orders. Devereaux is given Defend. On the other side of the field, Pembroke puts himself on Engage while the two wings opt for Maneuver orders.
 |
Let the battle begin! |
Straight away, Pembroke and Edward collide along the Old Roman Road. As the two bodies of men close, archers fire and retire to the rear. The two melee lines crash into each other with Edward and Pembroke leading the way. In the initial collision, men fall on both sides. Edward's battle takes the worst of the punishment and falls back. Edward is wounded in the chaos and is captured by the Lancastrians! Deja vu from the earlier game! DB cannot believe his luck but then neither can DC! Pembroke either fails to pursue or chooses not to do so. I don’t remember which! |
Pembroke and Edward clash... |
 |
and the Yorkists retire without Edward! |
Herbert, on the Yorkist Left continues his march toward Tudor while across the battlefield, Wiltshire takes the fight to Deveraux positioned on the Yorkist Right. |
With a slight lull in the center, the wings move into action. |
Tudor, who by now has successfully changed his orders to Engage, moves on Herbert. Herbert's archers are driven off and Tudor's melee line smacks into Herbert's melee line. Herbert suffers tremendous casualties and retires pushing his archers back as well. Tudor follows up but cannot reach Herbert's men to continue the melee. |
After driving off enemy archers, Tudor attacks! |
 |
Herbert's MAA are heavily bloodied and retreat. |
Back in the fight along the Old Roman Road, Edward (well, ex-Edward now), brings up his second body of MAA forward to engage Pembroke. Pembroke's first melee line stands firm and the Yorkists are repulsed. With the enemy falling back, Pembroke launches a counterattack. The Yorkists are forced back once again. Nearing exhaustion, Pembroke cannot break the enemy's will. The Yorkists stand firm and Pembroke retires. |
Yorkist MAA attack in the center... |
 |
and are driven off! |
 |
Pembroke pursues... |
 |
but cannot break the enemy's line. |
Against the Yorkist Right and Devereaux, Wiltshire goes in. In very heavy fighting, Devereaux is pushed back not once but twice! Wiltshire's success and tenacity pushes Devereaux and his Battle right off the table! One Yorkist Battle broken! |
Wiltshire attacks... |
 |
driving Devereaux clean off the table! |
The fighting in the center continues. Pembroke's first melee line attacks Edward's MAA. Stubbornly and somewhat unexpectedly, the Lancastrians are repulsed! As Pembroke's first line falls back, his second body of MAA advances to contact the enemy. The enemy is driven back in a chain reaction as formations behind are, likewise, pushed back. Edward's Battle clings to the edge of the board. With Wiltshire now unopposed on Edward's right ready to strike, Pembroke makes one more push into the wavering Yorkists. That one last shove is all that is needed to put Edward's Battle to flight. This battle is over. Victory to the Lancastrian Army and Pembroke! |
Pembroke renews his attack and is repulsed. |
 |
Lancastrian reinforcements join in pushing the enemy back. |
 |
Yorkist Center clings to the table... |
 |
but one last attack puts the Yorkists to flight! |
This was a convincing win by the Lancastrian Army as the Butcher's Bill, below, attests. Yikes! Congratulations to DC and Chris for a well-played game. Despite DB's seeming inability to put up a solid defense due to the Dice Gods, the Lancastrians capitalized on every Yorkist misstep and missed opportunity.  |
Butcher's Bill |
DB, that was a tough game, and another hard day for Edward. The dice rarely showed you any favor on this day. You took it all with grace. Usually, DC is on the end of terrible dice rolls so seeing DC's fortunes reverse was a positive even at your expense. We should bring you fellas back to the table for a rematch but, perhaps, a new battle.
Thanks again, guys! This was a very entertaining game.
Poor Edward! Great WotR gaming with your rules again, Jonathan!
ReplyDeletePoor Edward and DB, indeed!
DeleteClearly I have offended the Dice Gods...
DeletePerhaps the Dice Gods confused DB for DC?
DeleteWell that was a one sided affair! Great AAR and game Jonathan!
ReplyDeleteOne sided but fun to watch unfold. The Lancastrians never let up on the pressure.
DeleteI think I would have been tempted to put two players on the Yorkist side to reflect Edward's greater tactical ability; even though I'm more inclined to the Lancastrian cause, even I have to admit he seems to have been a more able commander! While it couldn't counter poor dice luck, two heads are usually better than one....☺
ReplyDeleteNeil
You may be right but sometimes two heads are not better than one! Of course, two Yorkists may have spread the dice luck around. Anyway, the players chose the commands they wished to play.
DeletePoor old Edward (ie DB). In other rules his constant rolling of sixes would be good news. Still, that’ll teach him for saying a Grimsby lad should be a Yorkist 😉.
ReplyDeleteA very enjoyable game. The rules were easy to learn with suitable period nuance.
Thanks Jon.
You are welcome, Chris! Your Lancastrians performed brilliantly!
DeleteLovely collection o.n show agains Jon and bloody work !
ReplyDeleteThanks, Matt! It was bloody work, no doubt.
DeleteGoodness me what a bad day for some. Nice looking figures.
ReplyDeleteFor the Yorkists, the day was very costly, no doubt.
DeleteA bad day for Eddy indeed Jon.
ReplyDeleteA tough battle for the poor Yorkists. It looked like they may have had more figures in the dead box than left on the table.
A great report as well.
Thank you, Ben! Since two the three Yorkist Battles were driven off table, there were definitely more Dead Pile than left standing.
DeleteGreat to see a new WoR game!
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed another iteration of this battle!
DeleteA very one-sided casualty count, and the AAR reflected a quick and decisive battle.
ReplyDeleteOne sided but still entertaining to watch develop. If not for bad luck, Edward might have had no luck at all.
Deletenapoleon was right, every general needs to be lucky, and Edward failed that test absolutely!
DeleteIndeed, he did!
DeleteA fair bit of medieval slaughter on show there and another defeat for York! The medieval world is askew🙂
ReplyDeleteSummed up nicely, Phil!
DeleteOuch! Good looking as always, bad luck on the one side for sure.
ReplyDeleteIt was tough to be Edward!
Deleteindeed, after a while I just became dispirited and wanted it to just end - at which point it's very hard to act positively to recover. 'the moral is to the physical as three is to one'...
DeleteDavid, I did not realize you had thrown in the towel. I thought you hung in there and went down swinging. You could have called Time Out and we could discuss next steps.
Deleteyeah, but just surrendering would have spoiled the others fun!
DeleteThat was a great game Jon! Poor Edward!!!
ReplyDeleteIt was a great game!
DeleteBlimey, poor old Eddie getting nabbed in the first melee! The butcher's bill photo speaks volumes. Just chalk it up as a bad day at the office;).
ReplyDeleteBad day at the office, for sure!
DeleteWow, looks like someone stole my dice. The Yorkists really took a pounding in this iteration of the game.
ReplyDeleteWhat's next Jonathan?
Richard, I am sure DB would gladly give your dice back! What's next? Good question. Should we stick with the WotR and dig up another battle?
Deleteoh man, the butchers bill / dead pile really shows it was a lopsided contest. Poor Dave looks like a game when one really needs a 6 and doesn't get it... repeatedly. 😁
ReplyDeleteDave got LOTS of 6s. What he needed was 1s!
DeleteInvariably it seemed, if I was rolling 2 dice, one them would come up '6'.. it felt like almost every time!
DeleteThat’s how it seemed to me, too, Dave.
DeleteAnother cracking game Jon, enjoyed reading the report.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Donnie!
DeleteA huge win for the Lancastrians! Maybe our friend Rick should try your rules, he seems very good at rolling low dice!
ReplyDeleteRichard did play the game and he won as the Lancastrians due, in part, to his propensity to roll low!
DeleteWell that was a bit of a disaster for me, right from the start when Edward was lost in the very first combat! After that nothing seemed to go my way, not sure I ever won a single round of combat, or at least that's how it felt! And those 6s just kept coming up on the dice...
ReplyDeleteDespite all that many thanks Jon, loads of fun and your rules are very good indeed!
Disaster, maybe, but we all have them. The good news is that there is always another game in which to redeem yourself. Happy to see that you still enjoyed the game!
DeleteIndeed, there's always another day and the game and rules were good - though there came a point when I just wanted it to be over!
DeleteA gentleman allows the other side to have their chance at glory and fun. While the Lancastrians had their fun, I suspect DC and Chris felt a twinge of guilt at seeing your incredibly bad luck.
DeleteThat's two each now isn't it Jonathan? The biggest winning margin of all too, I believe? Top stuff.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes, James
That IS two each! The Lancastrians are learning how to fight. This was the biggest winning margin of the four. You are paying close attention! Good job!
DeleteNothing beats two War of the Roses armies kicking the stuffing out of each other- great game!
ReplyDeleteI agree! Both battles were great fun to watch.
Delete